clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Reacting to Bauer's Top 100 Restaurants: Joy, Pain, Backlash

New, 1 comment

Well friends, the dust settled this weekend on Bauer's much-sweated annual list of Top 100 Bay Area Restaurants. But debates about his decision-making skills continue to swirl. Three ommissions from last year's list are no-brainers due to closure over the past months: Jack Falstaff, Cortez and Bistro Aix (which will reopen later this year); and it's no surprise Nick's Cove and Kokkari didn't make it, as we heard all about Bauer's sub-par '09 experiences at both. Before diving deeper, let's pause for a moment and digest this year's 18 rookies, in no particular order:

Baker & Banker, Nombe, Press (St. Helena), Tipsy Pig, Wexler’s, Etoile (Yountville), Frances, RN74, Sante (Sonoma), Solbar (Calistoga), Chapeau, Neela’s (Napa), Adesso (Oakland), Flour + Water, Osteria Stellina (Point Reyes Station), Scopa (Healdsburg), Frascati, Limon

On his blog post this morning, Bauer reveals the restaurants that were kicked off the list this year, conceding Moss Room, Gitane, Nettie's, and Matterhorn were particularly hard to let go. Keep in mind: in Sunday's print edition, Bauer fesses up to a bit of cheating. In two instances, he made room for newcomers by squeezing them onto an old listing: Barbacco/Perbacco and Pizzaiolo/Boot & Shoe Service. He also alludes to much difficulty with the final three cuts. We'd hazard, Moss Room and Nettie's were particularly hard for him to let go. Could it be Bauer had that much trouble discarding the fondue festival at Matterhorn?

· What would you add or subtract from the Chron Top 100 List? 2010 [Chowhound]
· What's in and what's out of the Top 100 restaurants [BauerBlog]

What's your feeling on the Top 100? Didn't Limon peak years ago? Is Tipsy Pig really that good? And isn't it a bit soon to be adding Frances? Release your thoughts to the world in the comments.

RN74

301 Mission Street, San Francisco, CA 94105 415 543 7474 Visit Website

Nombe

2491 Mission Street, San Francisco, CA 94110 (415) 681-7150 Visit Website

Baker & Banker

1701 Octavia Street, San Francisco, CA 94109 (415) 351-2500 Visit Website

Frances

3870 17th Street, , CA 94114 (415) 621-3870 Visit Website

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater San Francisco newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world