clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

San Francisco's 15 Must-Try New Winter Cocktails

View as Map

Slowly but surely, it's getting colder out there, and restaurants and bars across San Francisco have started to roll out winter cocktail lists, just in time. From creamy shaken egg nog, to melted hot buttered rums, to brandy-spiked this, and nutmeg-dusted that: here, now, the best new winter cocktails to keep you warm from the inside-out this season.


—Eva Frye

Read More
Note: Restaurants on this map are listed geographically.
If you buy something or book a reservation from an Eater link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics policy.

15 Romolo's Elf On The Shelf

Copy Link

15 Romolo is celebrating their Basque roots with a "Sherry Christmas" beverage menu, filled with sherry-spiked everything. Bartender Ian Adams says, "We all secretly love sherry and wanted to find a way to make it approachable... It's not just something that crazy Spanish grandmothers drink." Try an Elf on the Shelf (fino sherry, meletti ammaro, benedictine, blended scotch, bitters), which drinks like a Manhattan: full bodied, rich, semi-sweet with a touch of bitterness.

Lion Pub's Santa's DUI

Copy Link

If shots are your idea of festive, over in Pac heights you should get a Santa's DUI at Lion Pub. Bartenders shake up Fireball whiskey, sour apple schnapps, and cranberry for a spicy, tart, and ever-so-sweet shooter.

Maven's Fireside Cocktail

Copy Link

Kate Bolton combines Rittenhouse rye, apple, chestnut, her own winter spice blend, lemon and egg white. It shakes up to a spicy, cidery, frothy finished product.

Absinthe's Flaming Spanish Coffee

Copy Link

A hot Spanish Coffee is served aflame with 151-proof rum, ground cinnamon, hot coffee, Kahlúa, brandy, and whipped cream. Just remember to blow it out before sipping.

Bar Agricole's Made-To-Order Eggnog

Copy Link

Try the made-to-order eggnog at Bar Agricole, shaken with Strauss cream and County Line Harvest eggs, Marian Farms brandy, El Dorado rum, and finished with fresh grated nutmeg. They're also serving Glühwein, a German mulled red wine punch served warm with brandy and spices.

Locanda's Bad Seed

Copy Link

Bartender Gabe Lowe suggests the Bad Seed (applejack, Mezcal, grenadine, lemon) which tastes like a smokey apple pie. Or, go for the Chocolate Bourbon Flip (which isn't on the menu): Bourbon, Meletti Cioccolato ("an amazing chocolate liqueur made with unsweetened dutch cocoa"), and whole egg are shaken till it's rich and "frothy as hell," and served up with a grated nutmeg dusting.

Elixir's Hot Butt Rum

Copy Link

The Hott Butt rum includes brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, and cardamom, all mixed with vanilla ice cream that's melted down with hot water or cider and the increasingly rare Scarlet Ibis rum. It is rich and creamy. And it is fun to order too.

Starlight Room's Jack Holland Flip

Copy Link

Bols Genever, apple brandy, lemon, nutmeg-infused honey syrup, are shaken with a whole egg and grated cinnamon on top. Nothing like sipping this guy atop Union Square, just get there before 9 p.m. when the riff raff starts.

Jardinière's tequila hot chocolate with churros

Copy Link

Get the cayenne hot chocolate served with churros and dulce de leche on the side for dipping. Casa Noble Reposado gives it a south of the border boozy twist, or order it virgin.

Bar 888's Daily Press

Copy Link

Bar 888 in the Intercontinental has a hard nog, and a "Grinch Punch," but try the Daily Press: Bulleit, fresh apple cider, a cinnamon stick and coffee beans, served on the rocks. It normally goes for $12 or so, but you can score one for $8.88 during happy hour, which lasts until 8 p.m., weekdays.

Chambers Eat + Drink's Whisky Cider Flip

Copy Link

Drink # 14 is a nice compromise between eggnog and spiked cider. Bar Manager Richard Woodruff makes a Whiskey Cider Flip with house-made cider, citrus, egg, and nutmeg.

Reed And Greenough's rum flip

Copy Link

Run to Reed & Greenough for a rum flip: honey infused rum, scotch, cream, egg, and simple syrup, shaken and served frothy topped in cinnamon.

Top of the Mark's 12 Drummers Martini

Copy Link

Top of the Mark has several appropriately coined special cocktails right now, like the Twelve Drummers Martini (Godiva liqueur, vodka and peppermint schnapps), the 11 Pipers Piping Martini (scotch, Grand Marnier, honey, and a cinnamon stick, served hot), or 9 Ladies (Dancing) Martini (vanilla vodka, Frangelico, butterscotch schnapps, ginger beer, and dark rum). Drink one up with the city view.

Five's Three French Hen-nessey

Copy Link

Check out the Twelve Cocktails of Christmas in Berkeley at Five. Served all Decmember long, their list of 12 festive beverages range from items like the Pear Tree (pear vodka, ginger syrup, calamansi juice, lemon) to the aptly dubbed Three French Hen-nessey (Hennessey, crème de cassis, lemon).

Rich Table's Carthusian Hot Chocolate

Copy Link

Jason LoGrasso's new cocktail menu is ON in more ways than one: take this rich hot chocolate drink spiked with creme de menthe and chartreuse, then served with melty pineapple marshmallows.

15 Romolo's Elf On The Shelf

15 Romolo is celebrating their Basque roots with a "Sherry Christmas" beverage menu, filled with sherry-spiked everything. Bartender Ian Adams says, "We all secretly love sherry and wanted to find a way to make it approachable... It's not just something that crazy Spanish grandmothers drink." Try an Elf on the Shelf (fino sherry, meletti ammaro, benedictine, blended scotch, bitters), which drinks like a Manhattan: full bodied, rich, semi-sweet with a touch of bitterness.

Lion Pub's Santa's DUI

If shots are your idea of festive, over in Pac heights you should get a Santa's DUI at Lion Pub. Bartenders shake up Fireball whiskey, sour apple schnapps, and cranberry for a spicy, tart, and ever-so-sweet shooter.

Maven's Fireside Cocktail

Kate Bolton combines Rittenhouse rye, apple, chestnut, her own winter spice blend, lemon and egg white. It shakes up to a spicy, cidery, frothy finished product.

Absinthe's Flaming Spanish Coffee

A hot Spanish Coffee is served aflame with 151-proof rum, ground cinnamon, hot coffee, Kahlúa, brandy, and whipped cream. Just remember to blow it out before sipping.

Bar Agricole's Made-To-Order Eggnog

Try the made-to-order eggnog at Bar Agricole, shaken with Strauss cream and County Line Harvest eggs, Marian Farms brandy, El Dorado rum, and finished with fresh grated nutmeg. They're also serving Glühwein, a German mulled red wine punch served warm with brandy and spices.

Locanda's Bad Seed

Bartender Gabe Lowe suggests the Bad Seed (applejack, Mezcal, grenadine, lemon) which tastes like a smokey apple pie. Or, go for the Chocolate Bourbon Flip (which isn't on the menu): Bourbon, Meletti Cioccolato ("an amazing chocolate liqueur made with unsweetened dutch cocoa"), and whole egg are shaken till it's rich and "frothy as hell," and served up with a grated nutmeg dusting.

Elixir's Hot Butt Rum

The Hott Butt rum includes brown sugar, butter, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, and cardamom, all mixed with vanilla ice cream that's melted down with hot water or cider and the increasingly rare Scarlet Ibis rum. It is rich and creamy. And it is fun to order too.

Starlight Room's Jack Holland Flip

Bols Genever, apple brandy, lemon, nutmeg-infused honey syrup, are shaken with a whole egg and grated cinnamon on top. Nothing like sipping this guy atop Union Square, just get there before 9 p.m. when the riff raff starts.

Jardinière's tequila hot chocolate with churros

Get the cayenne hot chocolate served with churros and dulce de leche on the side for dipping. Casa Noble Reposado gives it a south of the border boozy twist, or order it virgin.

Bar 888's Daily Press

Bar 888 in the Intercontinental has a hard nog, and a "Grinch Punch," but try the Daily Press: Bulleit, fresh apple cider, a cinnamon stick and coffee beans, served on the rocks. It normally goes for $12 or so, but you can score one for $8.88 during happy hour, which lasts until 8 p.m., weekdays.

Chambers Eat + Drink's Whisky Cider Flip

Drink # 14 is a nice compromise between eggnog and spiked cider. Bar Manager Richard Woodruff makes a Whiskey Cider Flip with house-made cider, citrus, egg, and nutmeg.

Reed And Greenough's rum flip

Run to Reed & Greenough for a rum flip: honey infused rum, scotch, cream, egg, and simple syrup, shaken and served frothy topped in cinnamon.

Top of the Mark's 12 Drummers Martini

Top of the Mark has several appropriately coined special cocktails right now, like the Twelve Drummers Martini (Godiva liqueur, vodka and peppermint schnapps), the 11 Pipers Piping Martini (scotch, Grand Marnier, honey, and a cinnamon stick, served hot), or 9 Ladies (Dancing) Martini (vanilla vodka, Frangelico, butterscotch schnapps, ginger beer, and dark rum). Drink one up with the city view.